THE INCOMER (2O26) review
written by: Louis Paxton
produced by: Shirley O’Connor and Emily Gotto
directed by: Louis Paxton
rated: R (for brief graphic nudity)
runtime: 102 min.
U.S. release date: October 2, 2026 (Music Box Theatre, Chicago, IL)
Earlier this year at Sundance, Scottish writer/director Louis Paxton made his feature-length directorial debut with “The Incomer”, a whimsical modern-day folk tale that is as delightful as it is humorously life-affirming. Its Scottish Island setting recalls “The Banshees of Inisherin” and last year’s “The Ballad of Wallis Island”, not just for its similarly situated location, but also for the film’s sweetly odd, slightly absurd tone, which echoes “The Hunt for the Wilderpeople”. Paxton’s main trio of characters are outsiders who will have to figure out who they are, even if they’re peculiar, eccentric, or just plain weird. “The Incomer” often confidently waves its creative freak flag in unique ways, landing on poignant themes that are simply beautiful.
Set on a remote northeastern Scottish island, the film follows siblings Isla (Gayle Rankin) and Sandy (Grant O’Rourke), who have lived on their own for the past three decades. Their parents passed when they were young, and since then they have lived off the island, eating clams and netting gulls, making their own clothing or inheriting their parents’ wardrobe, along with their home. By all accounts, they should be feral, but somehow they’re not completely developmentally stunted. Sure, they wrestle each other with savage, albeit playful, intensity, but they also exhibit a touching love and protectiveness for each other. It quickly becomes clear that Isla has served as a default parent to the more childlike and naive Sandy. The one belief they’ve held on to, instilled by their parents, is to beware of Mainlanders and protect the island from “Incomers”.
One day, Daniel (Domhall Gleeson) sets foot on the wondrous yet forbidding isle. The redhead is a government lackey – a land recovery coordinator for the Northeastern Scottish Council, to be specific – and has arrived to serve any residents of the island with eviction notices. Though he is taken aback by the siblings’ makeshift suits of armor when they first meet, he still tells them they have thirty days to relocate to the mainland. The government considers them illegal residents, unaware of and uninterested in the siblings’ family ties to the island. Little does Daniel know that Isla and Sandy have experience removing “incomers” from their home, and the next thing he knows, he is knocked out and tied up.
It may be predictable that these three characters gradually develop a bond, but in this case, such predictability is like comfort food. It’s hard not to like them and enjoy their interaction, and the environment they are in. The affection for Scottish lore is present and visualized in loving and somewhat unsettling ways. The story’s mythical elements are also present without overwhelming its rich characterization. Sandy takes Daniel on a tour of the island, showing him his “secret place”, which is just a rocky coastline where he shouts at the raging sea, and Isla has a secret conversation with an aquatic creature known as Finman (an unrecognizable John Hannah), who wants to lure her into the sea, knowing she cannot swim. We learn more about these seal-men through lively animated segments by Selina Wagner, narrated by Isla, that tell the island’s history.
As Daniel begins to appreciate and understand the simple (and only) life Isla and Sandy have known, he starts questioning the integrity of his work. Early on, Paxton cuts to a brief flashback to the mainland, where we get a sense of what office life is like for Daniel. He’s often disregarded and treated by his manager, Roz (Michelle Gomez), as an afterthought, which is why she is quick to skuttle him off to the island with eviction papers. Daniel says he’s considered “weird” because of his love of fantasy and the fan-fiction stories he’s written, but on this island, where no one knows him, he’s seen as charming and quirky by the wary siblings. To fend off their attack, Daniel holds up his smartphone and proclaims he’s a wizard, playing majestic entrance music and taking their picture, which certainly surprises the captivating duo. It’s one of many humorous moments as Paxton settles into a wonderful rhythm and the trio becomes more and more endearing.
Watching this trio connect in unusual, sometimes awkward ways is enjoyable. Daniel exposes Sandy to new things, such as an electronic toothbrush, which he is fascinated by, and a banana, which he blurts, “My mouth is alive!” after his very first taste. Paxton carefully threads a plotline in which both siblings fall in love with Daniel in different ways, which could’ve been silly or cheesy, but instead becomes quite touching in their respective ways. The siblings are huge fans of storytelling, and become enraptured by the storytime Daniel provides, which becomes a fun running joke since it revolves around a character named Frodo.
“The Incomer” has an inevitable third act in which Roz lands on the island with a handful of subordinate goons, ordered to physically remove what she considers squatters. This comes after she sends a strange former employee named Callum (Emun Elliott), who arrived beforehand with gallons of urine for… hydration. The film culminates in an entertaining action sequence that starts with Isla and Sandy luring the newcomers into areas they know like the back of their hands. The melee ends in a delightfully heartwarming manner with one particular character jubilantly embracing a newfound status.
What “The Incomer” becomes is a touching reflection on the value of family, friendship, and the need for an accepting community. Paxton also considers whether modern civilization has any value, and for Isla and Sandy it does, as the film closes on a satisfying coda. “The Incomer” is the kind of film we need right now: a comforting, absorbing story that values human connection.
RATING: ***





